All along i read this:

Base percentage kept will drop to 20% for non-FFA servers (from 40%), with the addition of 0.06% per defend (of *THAT* country - not all countries all round) remaining the same
- The percentage of goods ON MARKET that are kept will be calculated separately with a base of 50% + 0.06% per defend (of *THAT* country - not all countries all round)


As 20% without walling (getting DHs), and 50% without walling (DHs). But really its you get .06% on every hit? Why do we get free percents when not playing the game? If it takes 200 hits "defends" to kill a country... its an extra 12% without any work from the player.

This doesnt make sense to me. All long i read defends to be defensive helds.

Think of it as realistic base %, but marketing says lets lower the % lower, but add a caveat that brings it back up.

On the other hand, the true intention is to reward walling.

difference to me is, u can thrash ur country while walling.. and not get a great deal back, when u might have nothing left to start with..

at worst restart might be w/o any buildings than cs's given.

Your restart will never be worse off than a brand new country. You can always drop land to 100, etc.

i understand that.. and thats not what im saying.. im saying depending on how much walling and how much damage done during walling.. a country that didnt wall might be better off

I.e. selling spies to buy troops, etc.

Xinhuan, what do you say to that, just curious.